Whereabouts

Miss Pell's case of the week · No. 3

The answer: The Churchyard Cat

A black cat had followed the club in at the lych gate, and nobody could catch it. When the lanterns were lit again, Clara lay in the Sexton's Hut.

Print the answer PDF, US Letter For a tablet PDF

Step by step

Every deduction, in order

  1. 1. Clue 1: Kit has 17 squares left.

    The plan after step 1.

  2. 2. Clue 3: Jack must be somewhere in column 2.

    The plan after step 2.

  3. 3. Clue 4: Peter must be somewhere in column 4.

    The plan after step 3.

  4. 4. Clue 2: Thomas has 7 squares left, and Martin has 7 squares left.

    The plan after step 4.

  5. 5. Clue 6: Kit has 13 squares left, and Lucy has 22 squares left.

    The plan after step 5.

  6. 6. Clue 7 settles it: Martin is at R1C5.

    The plan after step 6.

  7. 7. Clue 2 settles it: Thomas is at R2C7.

    The plan after step 7.

  8. 8. Jack has only one square left: R4C2.

    The plan after step 8.

  9. 9. Peter has only one square left: R7C4.

    The plan after step 9.

  10. 10. Clue 6: Lucy has 5 squares left.

    The plan after step 10.

  11. 11. Clue 8: Douglas must be somewhere in column 6.

    The plan after step 11.

  12. 12. Kit is the only suspect who can still stand in row 6, so they must be somewhere in it.

    The plan after step 12.

  13. 13. Kit has only one square left: R6C1.

    The plan after step 13.

  14. 14. Lucy is the only suspect who can still stand in column 3, so she must be somewhere in it.

    The plan after step 14.

  15. 15. Clue 5 settles it: Douglas is at R3C6.

    The plan after step 15.

  16. 16. Only one square is left for Lucy, so Lucy is at R5C3.

    The plan after step 16.

Who did it?

With the grid full, only Kit was in the Sexton's Hut with Clara. Kit is the murderer.

The finished plan, every suspect placed.
Back to the case

The Friday letter

Spend a Friday at Ashcombe Manor

Get a free sample case to print or solve on a tablet, with its answer step by step. Then the case of the week every Friday, with news and offers now and then. Unsubscribe in one click.

When one case is not enough

More murder mysteries from Ashcombe Manor

  • Murder in the Dark, a Whereabouts murder sudoku pack, as a pumpkin-orange case file, No. 3: a churchyard plan clipped inside, a keyhole onto a chapel altar with candle stands, three of five magnifying glasses stamped Gentle to Hard, 20 Cases. Four floor plans from the pack on four tablets: a churchyard at dusk, a seance at midnight, the cellars and a haunted chapel before dawn, each in pixel art with its furniture. The PDF's first page on a tablet, the pack's case-file cover, beside a list: 20 new illustrated mysteries on Halloween night, gentle, standard and hard, a practice case, hints and full solutions, a landscape PDF for tablets that prints.

    Murder in the Dark

    Twenty murder mysteries from one Halloween night at Ashcombe Manor, every suspect in costume.

    20 cases · Gentle to hard · PDF

    On Etsy
  • Whereabouts Murder Sudoku, the tablet edition: the Art Deco cover on a tablet, with two more tablets fanned behind it showing illustrated floor plans of a country house, one marked in pen. PDF for iPad and tablets, 50 cases.Tablet edition The paperback of Whereabouts: Murder Sudoku: its Art Deco cover, one lit room in a dark house, with seven suspects in a row below.Paperback What's inside the murder mystery puzzle book PDF: 50 illustrated cases and a practice case, four seasons, three levels of hints, a hidden message, 120 landscape pages made for tablets. The cover beside it.Tablet edition

    Whereabouts: Murder Sudoku

    The book: fifty murder mysteries from Ashcombe Manor, with three levels of hints for every case and every answer step by step.

    50 cases · Gentle to expert

    Tablet edition on Etsy Paperback on Amazon
  • The Beginner's Casebook, a Whereabouts murder sudoku pack, as a sage case file, No. 1: a lake plan clipped inside, a keyhole onto a lit drawing room with a chalk outline, two of five magnifying glasses stamped Gentle to Standard, 12 Cases. Four floor plans from the pack on four tablets: a garden with the great oak, a fountain court, the cellars, and a lake with a dock, each in pixel art with its furniture, most with a chalk outline. The PDF's first page on a tablet, the pack's case-file cover, beside a list: 12 new illustrated mysteries, six gentle and six standard, How to Play and a practice case, three levels of hints, solutions, a 44-page landscape PDF that also prints.

    The Beginner's Casebook

    Twelve new cases to start with, six gentle and six standard.

    12 cases · Gentle to standard · PDF

    On Etsy
  • The Expert's Casebook, a Whereabouts murder sudoku pack, as an oxblood case file, No. 2: a plan clipped inside, a keyhole onto a lit dining room with a chalk outline, five magnifying glasses stamped Hard to Expert, 12 Cases. Four floor plans from the pack on four tablets: a dining room with a long table, a garden with the great oak, a hedge maze and a chapel, each in pixel art with its furniture, most with a chalk outline. The PDF's first page on a tablet, the pack's case-file cover, beside a list: 12 new illustrated mysteries, six hard and six expert, the moves explained, a practice case, hints and full solutions, a 50-page landscape PDF made for tablets.

    The Expert's Casebook

    Twelve new hard and expert cases, for solvers who want a long evening.

    12 cases · Hard to expert · PDF

    On Etsy

Every free case